|
HOME
> TASTING
NOTES > CABERNET
SAUVIGNON of the 90s
|
CABERNET
SAUVIGNON of the 90s
|
|
January 10, 2000
Jon's Bear Club
|
The Caboose Decade of
the recently departed Millennial Train left fans of
California Cabernet Sauvignon quite a few nice souvenirs.
We tasted some that may be hard to find, but are
definitely worth the search. Jon's excellent pairing of a
beef tenderloin medallion under a seared slice of foie
gras, grilled scallion and rich glace de viande, followed
by a wedge of dark chocolate ganache, raspberry sauce
aside, made our event more enjoyable and our erstwhile
challenge more difficult. It took every bit of discipline
and imagination we could muster to rank this delicious
group. The point-spread was accordingly narrow and
rankings very close, with many stars and no losers here
(we are so spoiled!)...
Brand
Vintage,
Varietal or Type
Appellation
-$ price
(original release price)
|
Consensus
Tasting Notes
|
#Rank
Buying
Advice
|
|
Pride
Mountain
1997
Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley -
$32.
|
Opaque purple;
cassis, cola, blackberry, tobacco,cedar, pencil
shavings, pine, smoke, tar, oak and cocoa; ripe,
powerful, dense, extracted fruit with black
raspberry and sweet oak flavors, slightly cedary,
leathery, smoky; rich texture, mouth-filling, very
full body; good grip and big, well-integrated
tannins. Fairly priced.
|
#1
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Staglin
1996
Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley -
$45.
|
Deep
reddish-purple; intense berry-cherry, cassis, cola,
slight oak, eucalyptus, chocolate, anise; soft
entry, huge cherry fruit, spicy, sweet oak,
cinnamon, nutmeg, clove flavors; very rich, full
body; slightly tart balance; long, smooth, tannic
finish.
|
#2
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Caymus
1990
Cabernet Sauvignon
"Special
Selection"
Napa Valley ±$175. ($55.)
|
Deep red with a
garnet edge; heavy-toast oak, menthol, cedary,
cigar box, forest floor, weedy, rose hips, faint
caramel, smoke, leather, cherry and ethyl acetate;
sweet entry, rich cassis, cola, cherry, pepper,
dill and cedar flavors; slightly tart balance,
faint volatility; medium-full body; long, with
smooth, grapey-tart tannins. Ready to
drink.
|
#3
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Steven
Kent
1996
Cabernet Sauvignon
"Folkendt"
Livermore Valley -
$40.
|
Very dark purple;
big, dense, classic cassis, cola, cigar box, briar,
violet, cherry and berry nose with some vanilla
oak, mint, cinnamon and allspice; round, rich, ripe
cassis and black cherry flavors with hints of dill,
eucalyptus, cedar, spice and celery; full body with
some richness; Good balance; long, youthfully
tannic finish.
|
#4
Very
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Caymus
1994
Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley ±$75.
($35)
|
Medium-dark ruby;
complex bouquet overpowers varietal fruit with
dill, cinnamon, clove, cola, oak, pencil lead,
olive, spice, bacon, toast and charcoal with some
faintly leafy and musty notes; big, slightly woody,
boysenberry, bell-pepper and celery flavors; round,
mouth-filling, very good balance; slightly
astringent, very long finish; shone with
food.
|
#5
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Woodward
Canyon
1997
Cabernet Sauvignon
"Artist Series #6" Wash.-
$30.
|
Deep purple-red;
oak, toast, ash, very intense berry-cherry,
blueberry fruit with hints of violets, lavender,
caramel and chocolate; youthful, elegant, slightly
hard-edged flavors of blackberry, blueberry, spice;
good balance, seamless; light to medium body;
young, tight tannins.
|
#6
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Staglin
1994
Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley ±$55.00
($38)
|
Very deep ruby;
cassis, currants, berries, black licorice,
eucalyptus, briar, spice with some vanilla oak,
hint of brine or iodine; chocolate and herbal
flavors of cinnamon, dill and bay leaf could use
fruit; big, full body; well-balanced; somewhat
drying, faintly bitter tannins, long
finish.
|
#7
Highly
Recommended
|
|
J.
Lohr
1994
Cabernet Sauvignon
"Seven
Oaks"
Paso Robles ±$20.
($14)
|
Medium-dark,
youthful purple; raspberry, cassis, cherry, faintly
raisiny-pruney, weedy-minty with hints of smoke,
vanilla, cedar, pepper; herbal, tight, fruity black
cherry, cranberry flavors; light to medium body;
good balance, slightly tart; medium tannins, fairly
long, soft finish.
|
#8
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Chateau
Montelena
1993
Cabernet Sauvignon
"Calistoga
Cuvee"
Napa Valley ±$30.
($20)
|
Dark ruby with a
slight haze; sweet oak, cedar and eucalyptus aroma
over berries, somewhat closed-in, segmented; soft
entry, tight, mature cassis, tobacco and cedar
flavors are well-integrated; good balance; medium
body, some richness; medium-long finish.
|
#9
Highly
Recommended
|
|
Von
Strasser
1993
Cabernet Sauvignon
"Diamond Mountain"
Napa Valley ±$50. ($25)
|
Medium-dark ruby;
somewhat shy nose of dried cherry, berry, cassis,
faint dill, mint, smoke,brine, bark and funky must
(Brettanomyces?); fruity, somewhat lightweight
flavors; medium body; astringent, long finish with
slightly bitter, somewhat dusty tannins.
|
#10
Highly
Recommended
|
This
Panel
included Regulars Deanna, Glenn,
Diana, Roy,
Marlene, Jon, Jim, Chris, Ron, Greg, and
James
About
Cabernet Sauvignon
|
|