Taste masthead.



September 18, 2000 • Old Doc's Discount Liquors

Although we tossed any notions of appellation or vintage and decided to judge Chardonnay on price worthiness in the mid-to-premium range, we ended up with an all-California line-up and had examples that both undershot and overshot our price range. The panelists considerably preferred the top four finishers (average price $19.25)...one even earned "BEST BUY" honors...to the bottom five, which tend to have Quality/Price Ratios that seem to favor producers (avg. $25.70), rather than consumers.

Moral: Don't judge quality by price; you may pay too much for too little!

Varietal or Proprietary Type Vintage & Appellation
$ price - alcohol content

Compilation Tasting Notes
(bold type = consensus; ? = flaw?)
[technique, if known]
Buying Advice

1999 Chardonnay
Carneros "Sangiacomo"
$23. -

Medium straw; complex, peach pie, tropical, and grapefruit aromas with rich, toasty, honey, and vanilla bouquet; sweet entry, ripe, tropical, pineapple, well-integrated fruit flavors with noticeable oak; full body, tart, crisp balance; very clean, long finish with faintly harsh echoes of oak; seemingly high alcohol surprisingly unobtrusive. [French oak barrel-fermented, 100% malolactic & lees contact]

Very Highly

1998 Chardonnay ESTATE
Russian River Valley
$23. -

Medium straw; complex, fresh, ripe peach and hay aromas with butterscotch, sweet cream, vanilla, toast, spice, and a slightly musty bouquet; oaky entry, rich, citrussy, deep fruit flavors; crisp acidity, good balance; medium-long, slightly harsh (metallic?) finish. May improve with a few months bottle age. [unfiltered]

Very Highly

Thomas Fogarty
1998 Chardonnay
$18. -

Medium-dark yellow; complex, very ripe, lemon, pear and pineapple fruit aromas with spicy, resin (v.a.?), vanilla, caramel and barrel-fermentation bouquet; rich, woody, smoky, leesy flavors dominate floral, lemon, apple, pear, and fig fruit flavors; very smooth, round, creamy texture with nice harmony (fat?); smooth, medium-long finish, lingering oak with a faint bitterness. May improve.


1998 Chardonnay
Monterey "Pinnacles"
$13. -

Dark straw; sweet, straightforward, ripe tropical, pineapple, nectarine fruit aromas with sweet butter bouquet; fresh, charming, citrus, and stone fruit flavors with spice, honeysuckle, and barely noticeable wood; slightly rich, tart, crisp balance; clean, finish fades. Easy to drink now. [aged sur-lie, 7 months in French and American oak]



Pine Ridge
1997 Chardonnay "Dijon Clones"
Napa Valley - Carneros
$22.50 -

Dark straw; light apple and pineapple fruit aroma, touch of vanilla, toasted almond, and ginger spice; light, tart, lemon, green fruit flavors, very little oak (cedar?); elegant style, good balance; slightly bitter, medium-long finish.


1995 Chardonnay PRIVATE RESERVE
Napa Valley
$35. -

Medium-dark yellow; low-fruit lemony aroma with barrel-fermented, leesy, hazelnut, perfumed, faintly sherried (oxidation?) bouquet; mature flavors (bacon?), mask pineapple, tropical fruit, seems flat, flabby; fairly rich, creamy texture; woody, faintly harsh finish. The end is near---chill well and drink up. [aged sur lie, 9 months in French oak]


1998 Chardonnay "CUVEE"
$20. - 13%

Medium yellow; peach, melon, apple, tropical and bubble gum aromas are somewhat rich with a touch of spicy oak and an initial stench that dissipates; good mouthfeel and ripeness to the lemony fruit flavors; smooth, but slight heat offsets balance; long, slightly hot finish.


Long Vineyards
1997 Chardonnay
Russian River "Seghesio"
$21. - 13%

Medium straw; ripe tropical aroma with a faint (filter pad? butyl?) stench; lots of pleasant upfront oak flavors mask fig-like fruit; thin, low acidity; fairly long, rough, faintly harsh finish. [fermented and aged in new French Taransaud barrels]


Chalk Hill
1997 Chardonnay ESTATE
Chalk Hill, Sonoma County
$30. - 13.5%

Medium yellow; heavy oak aroma with low fruit gives impression of much older wine, funky, initial matchstick (SO2); somewhat harsh entry, ponderously woody, faint fruit, almost bland flavors with some tannin harshness; oily with a hollow center; long finish echoes wood. Not pleasant. (Very disappointing showing for this Wine Spectator 1999 TOP 100 List wine - could this be a [too] late bottling?)


This Panel included Regulars Mark, Deanna, Glenn,
Roy, Marlene, Jon, Ray, Jim, & James

Previous ChardonnayAbout Chardonnay




Includes: Why Wine? | Wine & Health | Social History | Sensory User's Manual | Grape Growing | Wine Making | Varietal Profiles | Sparkling Winebullet.Information on Reading Labels, Selecting and Buying Wine, Serving and Storing, etc.bullet.Taste includes the compiled tasting notes from our monthly panel, as well as reports on public tasting events, wherever we attend them, and notices of recurring wine events in Central California. There is also a Food & Wine section with a few wine-friendly recipes.bullet.In Aftertaste, see if you agree with our opinions and editorials in Wrath, find our Reading List and pages of links in Bacchanalia, to discover additional sources of wine information. You might also visit our Sponsors, who support this site.bullet.Contact information, short bios of the PfW tasting panel and the stories of PfW's formation and the web site genesis.

SEARCH: Match: Any All Exact (Spelling?)


Page updated October 5, 2001
Except as noted, site design & content © 1999-2002 by
Jim LaMar, WebDrone. All rights reserved.